Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Copyleft isn't really a good example. Let's talk about copyright. That fragment of code is not copyrightable on its own. Too small, too trivial.


Let's say I have 25 line function which does something novel and can be published as research (which I did, BTW, no joke), and I opened its reference implementation with AGPLv3+.

Is it again too trivial?


is 25 lines the limit then? do you count comments? can I codegolf a few lines to get below the limit?


> is 25 lines the limit then?

I don't know. That's my function's length.

> do you count comments?

No comments, no blank lines.

> can I codegolf a few lines to get below the limit?

You bet. But, if you copy my reference implementation, you need to get the license as well.

However, the research is on the open. Read it, implement it. That's no problem.

But, CoPilot is not reading my paper. It's reproducing my function verbatim, which is under a license which has share-alike mechanics.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: