Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What does gender have to do with opinions about whether someone should be able to rent out a room in a building they own?

Renters don't tend to look after properties. No, that's why it's called rent and they have property managers or landlords who have that responsibility. That said, I've been in my rented place for 12yrs and take good care of it, as do other tenants in our building. Myth busted.

How would I feel if someone opened a brothel? Not great, but then AirBnB doesn't really cater to brothel operations, and those don't usually fly by night so what point that is supposed to make other than setting up a BS false dichotomy (restrict renting or live with the sex trade next door).

Bars and clubs are regulated by zoning, so how would that ever happen?

The point is that a scummy hotel industry is trying to hedge out competition by using deep pockets to lobby local government into reinforcing their monopoly. Making apologies for them puts you against people like the guy in the article: hard times, tries to make a few extra bucks and gets shut down by the five cops at his door. Sound like America to you? Sound like he was opening a brothel? Look him in his unemployed eye and call the cops on him while you do.



The AirBnB brothel sounds like an intriguing idea.

I wonder if it exists? The room with a higher than expected rate and veiled hints of extra "amenities"...


On the other hand it is quite heartening that New York has improved to the point that this is now the top of the priority list for the police.

I remember New York when any murder of less than a dozen people wasn't worth bothering with.


Actually, this article reminded me of the "Gangs of New York", where cops and firemen were standing by a burning building, waiting for the occupants to leave, just so they could run in and take all the belongings.

Not saying this is the case, but not saying it isn't either.


they don't "own" the property and the word "owner" does not appear on anyone's deed (don't believe me? go read your own)

you are a tenant on the land, and your deed says this. the county is the owner.


I think you need to reread your deed, or move off of Section 8 housing. My deed explicitly states that I am the owner of my condo, as well as a % of the building and land on which the condo resides.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: