Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's pretty dumb. There are literally thousands upon thousands of companies you purchase from every single day where this happens or has happened. Why do you only care about Jobs?

Answer: because he was the only one brave enough to be this transparent. Literally all you're doing is encouraging everyone to hide this behavior as much as possible, and never EVER own up to it.



Alternate option: I also don't approve of those people either?


I'd day this ship has sailed when he became a celebrity.

Comment on him positively, you're now contributing to elevating his identity into something beyond human (etc.).

Comment on him negatively, and now you're just using him as a scapegoat (etc.).

It would seem like the real devil is in the asymmetry of significance, not in the people in question, or even the traits.


in what way does critiquing steve jobs convince the people being screwed over to not share?

i want courts to make it right, not for the swindlers to be confident talking about how they swindle people without consequence.

"owning up to it" is making it right, not chit chatting


It's possible to care about the practice of deception and also talk about one case.

Personally, I don't give much credit for "bravery" when it's expressed in terms of "being transparent" about being an asshole.


Do you give credit when people are brave enough to admit they have… positive traits? Why would someone even bother with saying that stuff?

“Everyone, I’m bravely showing you my spotless record” is really not an impressive showing. Being willing to completely upend your own reputation is.


I don't consider that bravery at all. So no.

I give more bravery points (which are worthless of course) to a whistle blower or someone running into a burning building to rescue the world's most tragic orphan.


Dang, that’s one unbelievably black and white world you live in. The nuance you miss must be book-worthy


I wouldn't know.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: