Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's excluding tax, net prices around 0.20-0.30 EUR / Kwh we common.


I updated my comment to include my personal delivered rate including VAT - also note that businesses (like a data center) don't pay the VAT and have substantially reduced delivery fees at high voltage


Then you're living in one of the cheapest areas for electricity prices in Europe, the opposite of what you said.

https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...

Scroll a little down and you see a breakdown by country

E.g.

https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...


I am in Lithuania, which has one of the highest wholesale energy prices in Europe (as per nord pool): https://data.nordpoolgroup.com/auction/day-ahead/prices?deli...

That it is not translating into a higher cost to the consumer (as evidenced on your link) is likely indicative of other costs being incurred by the “average” consumer in those countries with a higher domestic rate - like massive markup from users being tied into inflated contracts due to the 2022 shock where rates across Europe were more than double what they are now.

Also, these are residential prices - business prices are usually much lower (wholesale discounts, subsidies, no VAT, lower delivery charges).

As per my response to the initial comment - there is no way a datacentre in Europe is paying 30c/kWh


Business prices should be figure 6 in my link, while the difference is a lot smaller, Lithuania is definitely one of the cheaper countries, beating the EU average slightly.

> As per my response to the initial comment - there is no way a datacentre in Europe is paying 30c/kWh

Hetzner prices it at 33c/wh as of last year I believe, previously it was 40c (after the pipeline was destroyed)

But Germany is pretty much in the 3 most expensive countries wrt electricity cost in the EU - both for consumers and commercial pricing


> Lithuania is definitely one of the cheaper countries

And yet has one of the highest wholesale rates...

> Hetzner prices it at...

Hertzner are reselling. They make a profit on energy resale. Their rate also includes a substantial buffer on the actual rate to account for volatility. Their rate is most likely less than half of what they are passing on for colo.

For reference, last year German industrial energy prices were around 10c/kWh INCLUDING taxes and network fees - and the government are looking to subsidize that further to target 5c/kWh: https://www.gleisslutz.com/en/know-how/germany-cuts-costs-el...


You're talking about select industries which are being supported via subventions, data centers are not included. If you pay attention to the wording in your cited article, they've said so as well.

And hetzner does not have a large upsell for their energy prices, they're pretty much passing in the price as-is according to their own statements (from the large increase to 40c)

Almost all commercial applications need to pay the quoted prices around what's shown in figure 6


Ok, it seems I am mistaken that this subsidy applies to datacenter (apparently there is ongoing discussions to include them for this reason).

That said - I 100% don't believe that hertzner are simply passing on the price for their colo clients. Where did you read that they are not making a profit off electricity resale?

Here is another link discussing industrial energy prices WITHOUT reductions: https://www.smard.de/page/en/topic-article/213922/216044

So less than 17c/kWh in 2024, and likely another 2c when adjusted for current wholesale prices and network fees.


> That said - I 100% don't believe that hertzner are simply passing on the price for their colo clients. Where did you read that they are not making a profit off electricity resale?

That's indeed probably untrue, you're most likely correct there.

The statement was wrt the increase (they're passing on the increase in cost, not that they're mirroring the cost the energy provider!)

And after thinking about it some more, they absolutely have to make a significant upcharge, as they need to pay for wiring to the rented and housed devices, Large battery banks for temporary fail over and finally diesel generators if power is down for an extended period of time (that has all been demoed via YouTubers like derBauer )


Some countries also employ progressive electricity pricing such that higher energy consumption leads to elevated kWh rates incentivizing conservation. This is also not visible in the stats above. I also think that business kWh rates are actually higher than for the households in some instances.


Yeah, strictly business vs residential isn’t a good comparison either really, as the lower transmission fees for medium (10kV+) and higher voltage are where a lot of the savings are - and obv a lot of business don’t use such power.


Net is excluding tax, you mean gross.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: